High Court Nullifies Policy Merging ECDE and Primary Teacher Training Over Lack of Public Participation
The High Court has dealt a major blow to the Ministry of Education after declaring unconstitutional a policy seeking to merge Early Childhood Development Education (ECDE) teacher training with primary school teacher training. The decision marks a significant victory for early childhood education stakeholders who had challenged the government’s move, arguing that it was introduced without adequate public participation and could undermine the specialised training required by ECDE teachers.
In a judgment delivered on Thursday, November 19, 2026, Justice Patricia Mande nullified a circular issued by the Ministry of Education on January 19, 2026, which introduced changes to the existing teacher training programmes. The court found that the ministry had failed to provide documentary evidence showing that it consulted relevant stakeholders before implementing the policy.
The ruling is particularly important because it reinforces the constitutional requirement that government decisions affecting the public must be made through transparent and inclusive processes. Although the national government has the authority to formulate education policies, the court emphasised that such powers cannot be exercised without respecting the Constitution.
The decision brings renewed attention to the future of ECDE teacher training in Kenya, the responsibilities of different government institutions and the importance of involving teachers, training institutions, county governments and other stakeholders before introducing major reforms in the education sector.
At the centre of the dispute was the ministry’s decision to consolidate two separate teacher training programmes into one qualification. The proposed changes attracted opposition from education unions and other stakeholders, who argued that early childhood education requires specialised professional preparation that cannot simply be treated as an extension of primary school teaching.
How the controversial policy was introduced
The dispute began after the Ministry of Education, through the State Department for Basic Education, issued a circular dated January 19, 2026, communicating changes to the training of ECDE and primary school teachers.
The directive sought to merge the Diploma in Early Childhood Teacher Education (DECTE) with the Diploma in Primary Teacher Education (DPTE) to create a single qualification known as the Diploma in Teacher Education – Pre-Primary and Primary (DTE PP&P).
The circular also discontinued the Upgrade Diploma in Early Childhood Teacher Education (UDECTE), which had provided an opportunity for certificate-holding ECDE teachers to improve their academic and professional qualifications.
Under the changes, teacher training colleges were expected to adopt the new programme, while the Kenya National Examinations Council (KNEC) was directed to stop registering candidates under the discontinued courses. The ministry also instructed institutions to stop processing admissions and approvals for the affected programmes.
The Standard+1
The government appeared to be pursuing a more harmonised approach to teacher preparation, bringing pre-primary and primary education under a combined training structure.
However, the announcement immediately raised concerns among ECDE teachers, trainees and education institutions that had invested in specialised programmes.
Critics argued that the changes were too significant to be introduced through an administrative circular without adequate engagement with the people directly affected.
For many ECDE teachers, the proposed merger was not simply a change in the name of a qualification. It threatened to alter their professional training pathways, opportunities for career development and the structure of early childhood education.
The sudden discontinuation of existing programmes also created uncertainty among students who had already enrolled in colleges to pursue or upgrade their qualifications.
Some trainees were concerned about what would happen to their studies, fees and future professional opportunities if the programmes they had joined were no longer recognised under the new arrangement.
The controversy consequently developed into a wider debate about the direction of early childhood education and whether the government had followed the correct procedures when introducing the reforms.
Why ECDE teachers and education stakeholders opposed the merger
The Kenya Union of Pre-Primary Education Teachers challenged the ministry’s decision, arguing that the policy was unconstitutional because it had been introduced without adequate public participation.
The union maintained that ECDE is a specialised area of education requiring distinct professional skills and training approaches.
Unlike primary school teaching, which focuses on structured learning across different subjects and academic levels, early childhood education involves preparing young children for formal learning through age-appropriate teaching methods.
At this stage, children are still developing essential communication, social, emotional, physical and cognitive skills. Teachers therefore require specialised knowledge to understand how young learners develop and how different teaching approaches can support their progress.
ECDE education also places significant emphasis on play-based learning, interaction, creativity and activities that help children understand their environment.
Education stakeholders warned that combining the training programmes without adequately considering these differences could weaken the professional preparation of teachers responsible for the country’s youngest learners.
They also raised concerns about the possible disruption of existing training institutions and the career progression of teachers who had enrolled in ECDE upgrade programmes.
The debate extended beyond teachers and training colleges, attracting the attention of county governments and lawmakers.
County governments expressed concern because ECDE is a devolved function under Kenya’s constitutional framework. Counties are responsible for early childhood education services, including the management of ECDE centres and the employment of teachers within their respective jurisdictions.
Governors argued that they should have been consulted before the ministry introduced changes that could affect the management and delivery of early childhood education.
Senators also questioned the proposed merger, warning that it could create uncertainty for counties, training institutions and learners. They emphasised that any major reforms affecting ECDE should involve extensive consultations and respect the constitutional division of responsibilities between national and county governments.
The Eastleigh Voice+1
The concerns demonstrated that the dispute was not limited to the academic structure of teacher training. It also involved questions about devolution, professional standards, institutional responsibilities and the future quality of foundational learning in Kenya.
What the High Court said in its ruling
In determining the case, Justice Patricia Mande examined whether the Ministry of Education had acted within its constitutional mandate and whether the process leading to the January 19 circular complied with the law.
The court acknowledged that the national government has the constitutional authority to formulate education policies and oversee matters such as education standards, curricula and examinations.
However, the judge emphasised that the existence of such authority does not give government institutions unlimited power to introduce policies without following constitutional procedures.
Justice Mande relied on Article 10 of the Constitution, which identifies public participation as one of the national values and principles of governance.
The provision requires public institutions to involve citizens and relevant stakeholders in decisions that affect them.
The judge explained that public participation must be meaningful rather than a symbolic exercise conducted merely to satisfy a constitutional requirement.
She observed that the ministry had claimed to have conducted extensive consultations across the country and engaged relevant stakeholders before introducing the changes.
However, it failed to present documentary evidence, including consultation reports and records of stakeholder engagements, to support those claims.
This failure became a central issue in the court’s determination.
The judge held that where a government policy is challenged on grounds of inadequate public participation, the responsible public authority must demonstrate that the constitutional requirements were fulfilled.
Simply stating that consultations took place is not sufficient. Government institutions must be able to provide evidence showing who was consulted, how the engagements were conducted and whether the views collected were considered during the decision-making process.
In the absence of such evidence, the court found that the ministry had failed to establish that the policy was developed through a constitutionally acceptable process.
Justice Mande consequently declared the January 19, 2026 circular unconstitutional and issued an order quashing it.
The Eastleigh Voice+1
The judgment sends a strong message to government institutions that policy decisions must be supported by transparent and verifiable consultation processes.
It also reinforces the principle that public participation is not optional whenever government decisions have significant consequences for citizens and professional groups.
Why the ruling matters to ECDE teachers and trainees
The judgment is expected to bring relief to ECDE teachers, students and training institutions that had raised concerns about the proposed merger.
By nullifying the circular, the court has removed the legal foundation of the ministry’s January directive.
The ruling is particularly important for teachers who were pursuing additional qualifications through the ECDE upgrade programme.
Before the proposed changes, the upgrade pathway offered certificate-holding teachers an opportunity to improve their professional qualifications and expand their career prospects.
The discontinuation of the programme had raised questions about the future of students who were already enrolled and institutions that had invested resources in offering the courses.
The court’s decision therefore provides an important legal development for stakeholders who had challenged the abrupt changes.
However, the ruling should not automatically be interpreted as resolving every administrative question concerning individual trainees, admissions or the future structure of teacher training. Those matters may require further guidance from the relevant education authorities.
The ministry will also need to consider how to proceed if it still intends to reform ECDE teacher training.
Any future policy changes must comply with the constitutional requirements highlighted by the court.
This means that the government cannot simply reintroduce the same directive without addressing the shortcomings identified in the judgment.
Meaningful engagement with teachers, unions, county governments, training institutions and other affected groups will be essential.
The ruling also gives education stakeholders an opportunity to present their concerns and proposals before any new framework is introduced.
A major lesson for the Ministry of Education and government institutions
Beyond the immediate dispute, the judgment carries wider implications for how public policies are developed and implemented in Kenya.
Government institutions regularly introduce reforms intended to improve service delivery, strengthen institutions and respond to changing national needs.
However, even policies designed with good intentions must follow the Constitution and respect the rights of people affected by their implementation.
Public participation allows citizens and professional groups to contribute information that policymakers may not have considered.
In the education sector, teachers understand the practical challenges of classrooms, while training institutions have experience in preparing professionals for different learning environments.
County governments also understand the financial and administrative responsibilities involved in delivering ECDE services.
Excluding these stakeholders from major decisions can result in policies that create confusion, face resistance or fail to address the actual challenges affecting the sector.
The court’s ruling therefore highlights the importance of consultation not only as a legal requirement but also as a tool for improving the quality of public policy.
It reminds government officials that public participation must take place before major decisions are implemented, rather than being treated as an administrative formality after the policy has already been announced.
The case also demonstrates the importance of keeping proper records of public consultations.
Where a ministry claims to have engaged stakeholders, it should maintain clear documentation showing the nature of those engagements and how the views received influenced the final decision.
Such records help demonstrate accountability and protect government policies from legal challenges arising from procedural failures.
What happens next?
Following the High Court’s decision, attention now shifts to the Ministry of Education and how it intends to handle the future of ECDE teacher training.
The government may need to review its proposed reforms and develop a new approach that addresses the concerns raised by teachers, training institutions and county governments.
If the ministry believes that combining aspects of pre-primary and primary teacher training would improve the education system, it will have to demonstrate why the changes are necessary and engage affected stakeholders before introducing another policy.
The Teachers Service Commission, Kenya Institute of Curriculum Development, county governments and professional organisations are also likely to remain important participants in discussions about teacher preparation and professional standards.
For now, the ruling provides an important reminder that education reforms must be guided by evidence, consultation and constitutional principles.
The future of early childhood education is particularly important because the foundation children receive during their early years can influence their performance and development throughout their education journey.
Ensuring that teachers have the appropriate training, skills and professional support is therefore essential to the success of Kenya’s education system.
Ultimately, the High Court’s decision is more than a setback for the Ministry of Education. It is a significant affirmation of the constitutional right to public participation and the responsibility of government institutions to remain accountable when making decisions that affect the public.
As the debate over teacher training continues, the challenge will be to develop reforms that improve the quality of education without undermining specialised professional training or excluding the people expected to implement those changes.
For ECDE teachers and trainees, the judgment offers an important legal victory. For the government, it presents an opportunity to rethink its approach and ensure that future education policies are developed through inclusive, transparent and constitutionally sound processes.


